Academics, Division of
Page Navigation
- Cleveland Metropolitan School District
- Parents' Bill of Rights
-
Parents’ Bill of Rights
District Procedures for Submission of Written Concerns
Objections may be raised in the following areas:- Instructional materials: Concerns about instructional materials, particularly those containing sexuality content. HB 8 requires schools to notify parents of their right to review such materials and potentially request alternative instruction.
- Student health and well-being: Concerns regarding your child's mental, emotional, or physical health or well-being, or changes in related services or monitoring.
- Other topics covered by House Bill 8.
To initiate a concern, a parent/guardian must be a parent or permanent guardian of students in CMSD. When an individual raises a concern, the school and district should respect the rights of that individual and the rights of others who may view the material differently.-
Initial Objection: The material in question shall remain in use unless removed through the procedure in this section. If a concern is lifted, the Principal or designee should:
- Listen to the parent/guardian's concerns and make reasonable efforts to resolve the issue;
- Explain the selection process utilized and offer alternative assignments if appropriate and consistent with curriculum requirements;
- Refrain from voicing a personal opinion;
- The Principal or designee should document this concern
- If the parent/guardian raising the concern is not satisfied with this initial resolution of the situation, the Principal or designee should direct the parent/guardian to file a written concern using the “Parents’ Bill of Rights Submission of Written Concern Form” while refraining from expressing personal opinion.
-
Formal Complaint: If, after consultation, the parent/guardian desires to submit a written concern, a copy of the “Parents’ Bill of Rights Submission of Written Concern Form” should be given to the person by the Principal or designee.
-
The “Parents’ Bill of Rights Submission of Written Concern Form” should be:
- Completed by the parent/guardian expressing the concern
- Once completed, the form will automatically be sent to the Deputy Chiefs of Teaching and Learning and Schools, the Executive Director of Curriculum and Instruction, and the Director of Library/Media Services.
-
Upon completion of the “Parents’ Bill of Rights Submission of Written Concern Form”, the parent/guardian expressing the concern will be automatically notified in writing that the form has been received and that the District’s review process has been initiated.
-
A parent/guardian expressing a concern may request alternative assignments for his/her student. Any alternative assignments must be appropriate and consistent with curriculum requirements.
-
Review of Written Concerns: The review process is as follows:
-
Any action taken related to challenged materials should be taken by action of the entire Parents’ Bill of Rights Review Committee and not by an individual, including the Principal.
-
The Parents’ Bill of Rights Review Committee will be comprised of the Executive Director of Curriculum and Instruction, Director of Library/Media Services, four Community, College, and Career Center Coordinators (5 C’s), and the Executive Director of Integrated Health
-
The Parents’ Bill of Rights Review Committee should meet and render a decision after receipt of the “Parents’ Bill of Rights Submission of Written Concern Form”. The concern should be resolved within 30 days of receipt of the completed form.
-
Before evaluating the concern, Committee members should:
-
Read, view, or listen to the material in question in its entirety,
-
Read the “Parents’ Bill of Rights Submission of Written Concern Form” completed by the complainant,
-
Read available professional evaluations about the material under review. The Director of Library/Media Services should compile necessary professional evaluations of the material in question.
-
-
When Committee members have completed the steps outlined above, the School Parents’ Bill of Rights Review Committee should meet to:
-
Review the concerns expressed,
-
Discuss the materials relative to appropriateness to grade level and curriculum. In determining the suitability and value of the material, the Committee should consider the following:
- Relevance;
- Pervasive vulgarity;
- Quality, content, and manner of presentation, and appropriateness to age, sophistication, and grade level of students; and
- Space limitations and obsolescence.
-
Render a majority decision relative to requested actions as long as a quorum is present. The decision should be communicated to the Principal and may be to:
- Take no removal action;
- Remove the material of concern from the local school if the Committee finds the material is pervasively vulgar and/or lacking in educational value throughout;
- Place the material at another school level;
- Regulate the assignment of the material.
-
-
-
Notification: Within five (5) working days of the Parents’ Bill of Rights Review Committee’s decision, the final decision will be sent to the parent/guardian and principal in writing.
-
Implementation of a decision rendered by the school or Parents’ Bill of Rights Review Committee should be upheld.
-
-
Review of Selection and Appeal Procedures
- The Director of Library/Media Services should annually communicate selection criteria and the written concern procedures with all library media specialists and Principals.
- The Principal or designee should review the selection criteria and written concern procedures with all staff annually.
- The staff should be reminded that the right to object to the material is granted by House Bill 8.
- The Director of Library/Media Services should annually review the selection procedures to determine if revisions are needed.
